How Beautiful We Were

How Beautiful We Were

  • Downloads:5956
  • Type:Epub+TxT+PDF+Mobi
  • Create Date:2021-05-03 08:52:59
  • Update Date:2025-09-06
  • Status:finish
  • Author:Imbolo Mbue
  • ISBN:1838851348
  • Environment:PC/Android/iPhone/iPad/Kindle

Summary

From the celebrated author of the New York Times bestseller Behold the Dreamers, comes a sweeping, wrenching story about the collision of a small African village and an America oil company。

"We should have known the end was near。"

So begins Imbolo Mbue’s powerful second novel, How Beautiful We Were。 Set in the fictional African village of Kosawa, it tells the story of a people living in fear amidst environmental degradation wrought by an American oil company。

Pipeline spills have rendered farmlands infertile。 Children are dying from drinking toxic water。 Promises of clean-up and financial reparations to the villagers are made—and ignored。 The country’s government, led by a brazen dictator, exists to serve its own interest。 Left with few choices, the people of Kosawa decide to fight back。 Their struggle would last for decades and come at a steep price。

Told through the perspective of a generation of children and the family of a girl named Thula who grows up to become a revolutionary, How Beautiful We Were is a masterful exploration of what happens when the reckless drive for profit, coupled with the ghost of colonialism, comes up against one community’s determination to hold onto its ancestral land and a young woman’s willingness to sacrifice everything for the sake of her people’s freedom。

"The unforgettable story of a community on the wrong end of Western greed, How Beautiful We Were will enthrall you, appall you, and show you what is possible when a few people stand up and say this is not right。 A masterful novel by a spellbinding writer engaged with the most urgent questions of our day。”—David Ebershoff, bestselling author of The Danish Girl

Download

Reviews

Anuradha

Thanks Netgalley and Random House for the eARC!Have you ever read the infamous Larry Summers "Let Them Eat Pollution" memo? If you haven't, this book is a good reason to do so。 Mostly because it represents what would happen if we do, in fact, let them eat pollution。How Beautiful We Were is Imbolo Mbue's stunning second novel about a fictional village in Africa, Kosawa, and everything that happens to it after the government sells oil rights from that village to a big American oil corporation, Pex Thanks Netgalley and Random House for the eARC!Have you ever read the infamous Larry Summers "Let Them Eat Pollution" memo? If you haven't, this book is a good reason to do so。 Mostly because it represents what would happen if we do, in fact, let them eat pollution。How Beautiful We Were is Imbolo Mbue's stunning second novel about a fictional village in Africa, Kosawa, and everything that happens to it after the government sells oil rights from that village to a big American oil corporation, Pexton。 The story is told by different people in the village, in particular, focusing on Thula Nangi and her family。 As people that know me are aware, I am a big fan of any form of non-traditional storytelling, when it's done well。 Here。 it's done well。 Having multiple narrators, and narratives works well in this story because it offers multiple perspectives into the same issue。 The obvious problem with this is that there is some definite repetition of what happened at a particular time, although I do think that in this particular case, that problem takes care of itself。 The story isn't supposed to be a recollection of events that happened in chronological order, but rather a litany of how each of these people felt about each event, and then all of them。 It is a study in the overt ways, and the subtle ways that patriarchy, racism, and plain ignorance affects the people of the village, just as much as it is a story of what life used to be there, and what it has become。 Mbue took a gamble here, with this kind of story-telling, because it could have not worked in really bad ways。 It could have been tedious; in fact it barely does skim that line in certain cases, but Mbue is a good enough writer and a strong enough storyteller to be able to pull back before it does。 It takes a leaf out of Jose Saramago's method of using some vagueness to articulate how commonplace these fictional events can actually be。 (I'm sure other authors have done this, but I attribute it to Saramago because of how well he does it。) Kosawa could be just about any village in any country in Africa, and Pexton could be just about any big corporation on the hunt for resources。 This intentional vagueness works in favour of the story, because Kosawa, and Pexton both work as characters themselves。 It's not just the people of Kosawa we feel sympathetic for, but the village itself, for all that it's suffered with its land and water and forest。 It's not just the people of Pexton we feel outraged towards, but Pexton itself, hiding behind the loopholes of the law, and sucking the life out of both people and places。 Was money so important that they could sell children to strangers seeking oil? As it turns out, it was。 I've worked in development。 I can offer theories and statistics about the poverty paradox as well as anyone else。 How Beautiful We Were is a work of fiction, so it goes beyond the theories and statistics。 It offers spirit, soul, and substance。 But best of all, it works because it offers nuance。 。。。more

Ellen

I wanted to love this - I did love Behold the Dreamers - but I never found myself wanting to read any more。 A familiar story of a greedy American corporation poisoning the soil, air and water of a village in Cameroon it had an inevitability and kind of sick tension I found unbearable。

Julia

The village has a soul, but the country does not。 I checked some reviews after I finished the book, and I did not find the optimism that the reviewers did。 I think the book is overrated。 It starts out with fantastic storytelling but turns into a bit of an anticlimactic slog toward the depressing end。 Point made。

Jordan Chapman

Beautifully written and bsolutely relentless。 This one will stick with me for some time

Makayla

If I could do half points, this would be a 3。5, but alas。 Overall the story was good and I feel it's an important story to tell, of something that is happening all too often all over the world。 That said, I sometimes struggled with some of the longer prose writing and the jumping POVs throughout the book。 And too often characters would be thinking about sex or their own bodies in a way that threw me off and sometimes felt out of place。 That said, it was still enjoyable。 If I could do half points, this would be a 3。5, but alas。 Overall the story was good and I feel it's an important story to tell, of something that is happening all too often all over the world。 That said, I sometimes struggled with some of the longer prose writing and the jumping POVs throughout the book。 And too often characters would be thinking about sex or their own bodies in a way that threw me off and sometimes felt out of place。 That said, it was still enjoyable。 。。。more

Pam Moore

DNF

Amy

Rounding up a bit。 Some segments felt much longer than they needed to be。 Very good story though。

Bonnie。rabinowitxgmail。com

I would have rated this a 5 if it had been shorter。

Alice

4。5 / 5Beautiful, and a great audiobook I highly recommend。TW : massacres, death of children and loved ones, rape, pedophilia。。。

Carolyn

CSD loved so far

Manasa

“No matter where they go, they carry their birthplace, never apart from all that it gave and took away from them。 They seek its warm air on cold days, imagine its sunshine when clouds cannot be subdued。 They see long-lost faces in a sea of strangers。 They hear a voice and remember a story from a distant evening。 A love song breaks their heat, for they yearn for their motherland to hold them, caress them, whisper in their ears。 It will never be so again; those days are far gone。 But the nostalgia “No matter where they go, they carry their birthplace, never apart from all that it gave and took away from them。 They seek its warm air on cold days, imagine its sunshine when clouds cannot be subdued。 They see long-lost faces in a sea of strangers。 They hear a voice and remember a story from a distant evening。 A love song breaks their heat, for they yearn for their motherland to hold them, caress them, whisper in their ears。 It will never be so again; those days are far gone。 But the nostalgia, it makes crybabies out of grown men on the darkest of nights- many of them will never be whole again。 They’ll be forever poorly patched and existing in a world that had little time to ask them to tell their stories- who cares for their stories?” 。。。more

Stephanie

A beautiful book。 I found it a little disjointed and winding but quite compelling。

Joanne

A U。S。 oil company pollutes the lands of a village in an un-named corrupt country in Africa。 The people in the village try for years and years to stop it。 They persist despite their children dying, and they work and work for justice。 There's a definite hard-to-read theme of violence against women, who are the under-appreciated strength that allows the people to survive at all。 A U。S。 oil company pollutes the lands of a village in an un-named corrupt country in Africa。 The people in the village try for years and years to stop it。 They persist despite their children dying, and they work and work for justice。 There's a definite hard-to-read theme of violence against women, who are the under-appreciated strength that allows the people to survive at all。 。。。more

Jim Shubnell

A good read but a bit long!

Deborah Pinkus

A moving and powerful story,not a happy one。It could have used editing! Last third too dragged out。

Gina

Two for two for this author。 Loved her first book and now this second book is extraordinary。 Can't wait for more books from Imbolo Mbue。 Two for two for this author。 Loved her first book and now this second book is extraordinary。 Can't wait for more books from Imbolo Mbue。 。。。more

Colleen Marsh

4。7

Rob

A heartbreaking story of a small African village's fight for justice with a large American oil company。 Told over the course of several decades, and featuring a host of narrators, How Beautiful We Were is Imbolo Mbue's ambitious follow up to her incredible first novel, Behold the Dreamers。 This novel, however, lacks the precision we find in Behold The Dreamers。 Everything is ramped up, and I felt at times that the story got away from itself。 The entire book was enlightening and worth reading A heartbreaking story of a small African village's fight for justice with a large American oil company。 Told over the course of several decades, and featuring a host of narrators, How Beautiful We Were is Imbolo Mbue's ambitious follow up to her incredible first novel, Behold the Dreamers。 This novel, however, lacks the precision we find in Behold The Dreamers。 Everything is ramped up, and I felt at times that the story got away from itself。 The entire book was enlightening and worth reading, but the pacing was a bit strenuous at times。 Additionally, the novel jumps through time and features multiple narrators, which made it a bit of a challenge to listen to the audiobook version。 。。。more

Sana Dinalang

Reading a good story like this one, I suggest you join Novel Star’s writing competition on April

Jordan Davidson

This book is hatefully sad, rather long, and somewhat slow in pacing。 It’s also exquisitely beautiful and one of the few books that’s touched my cold wrinkled walnut of a heart in recent years。 By far my favorite book of 2021 so far, and the newest addition to my “recommend to everyone” list。

Becky

2。5 stars This is the story of a fictional African village, Kosawa, amidst environmental disaster due to the oil boom, in the aftermath of colonialism。 I loved Mbue’s Behold the Beautiful Dreamers and I had been anxiously waiting for her next novel。 I appreciated the message behind this story, broad in scope but I’ll dial it down to this - how greed destroys, how the world is constantly changing, and what little we may have left for generations to come。 I wanted to love this book。 I love the ide 2。5 stars This is the story of a fictional African village, Kosawa, amidst environmental disaster due to the oil boom, in the aftermath of colonialism。 I loved Mbue’s Behold the Beautiful Dreamers and I had been anxiously waiting for her next novel。 I appreciated the message behind this story, broad in scope but I’ll dial it down to this - how greed destroys, how the world is constantly changing, and what little we may have left for generations to come。 I wanted to love this book。 I love the idea of this book and I love the author but I barely even liked the book。 Something held me back, maybe the change in narration, maybe the fictional setting I just couldn’t place, (which is the point of a fictional setting but。。。), maybe the epic sadness that was unrelenting。 I do not shy away from sad stories, I yearn to be brought to tears! But this wasn’t that kind of book。 It was sad without being moving。 I really struggled with this one。 。。。more

Jenny Belardi

I can't do it。 I wanted to love this。 The story is right up my alley, but I just can't get past the "we" narrator。 I can't do it。 I wanted to love this。 The story is right up my alley, but I just can't get past the "we" narrator。 。。。more

Jennifer Cutler

I have no words。 Except these: people are horrible。 This was a gut-wrenching tale of economic imperialism at its worst (perhaps its "only。") I have no words。 Except these: people are horrible。 This was a gut-wrenching tale of economic imperialism at its worst (perhaps its "only。") 。。。more

Patsey

Oil is pointy。 (Thank you Dr Warner)。 How very different things are if oil is under Saudi Arabia or Texas or Nigeria。 How different the riches are to those who live above it。 Ms Mbue is a fantastic writer。 Her words hit like darts and I felt the pain and heartbreak。 Yaya’s section was especially poignant。 A book everyone should read。 p。 261“How often did the laborers question the value of their lives? Did they cry at night in regret? Whenever we saw one of them at the bus stop with a packed trun Oil is pointy。 (Thank you Dr Warner)。 How very different things are if oil is under Saudi Arabia or Texas or Nigeria。 How different the riches are to those who live above it。 Ms Mbue is a fantastic writer。 Her words hit like darts and I felt the pain and heartbreak。 Yaya’s section was especially poignant。 A book everyone should read。 p。 261“How often did the laborers question the value of their lives? Did they cry at night in regret? Whenever we saw one of them at the bus stop with a packed trunk, having decided that the prospect of riches was no match for a simple life of love and quiet, we knew not whether to admire the man or scoff at his weakness in fleeing。”p。 297“They had gained entrance into the school by virtue of their connections to powerful men—when did people ever rise up to put an end to their own privilege?” 。。。more

Beth

Reading this story requires attention, thoughfulness, even mindfulness。 For it is a story of an African town where American greed has ruined the environment。 It offers prescience of what is really happening throughout the globe。 Like the current pandemic that reuins health globally, when the ecosystem is damaged, so will mankind be。 It is a story of a village trying to believe in hope that the oil company will through the efforts of Tula correct the damages they have wroght and pay compensation。 Reading this story requires attention, thoughfulness, even mindfulness。 For it is a story of an African town where American greed has ruined the environment。 It offers prescience of what is really happening throughout the globe。 Like the current pandemic that reuins health globally, when the ecosystem is damaged, so will mankind be。 It is a story of a village trying to believe in hope that the oil company will through the efforts of Tula correct the damages they have wroght and pay compensation。 It never happens; this is not your "everything ends well" kind of book。 It is a warning that as the earth is damaged, so is culture, spirituality, peoples health, and the food they eat。I enjoyed the earlier part of the story showing time of effort and hopefullness。 The author's strength lies in letting one in on vanishing village life。 It is a story that needs told and visualized with understanding 。 What it can't show is what effort and resolution it would really take to stop earth-damaging practices that hurt civilization。 But no one seems to be able to effect such solutions。 。。。more

Danielle Violet

I cannot begin to comprehend how Imbolo Mbue managed to perfectly capture and portray the realities of governance, international law, human rights, tribal relations/customs, and the delicate spaces where magic and hope can be found。 She weaves enormous aspects of society into the most simple and humble storyline。 Mbue is an author after my own heart, giving each character ample space to share their perspective and support the reader’s understanding of their motives, desires and dreams, while als I cannot begin to comprehend how Imbolo Mbue managed to perfectly capture and portray the realities of governance, international law, human rights, tribal relations/customs, and the delicate spaces where magic and hope can be found。 She weaves enormous aspects of society into the most simple and humble storyline。 Mbue is an author after my own heart, giving each character ample space to share their perspective and support the reader’s understanding of their motives, desires and dreams, while also staying true to the overarching narrative。 I just about fell to pieces at the end, but every piece was that much more informed and aware than it had been before reading this masterpiece。 Mbue gets every single one of my stars <3 。。。more

Paula

A beautifully written story that while set in a fictional African community could easily be set in many places in America。 The story of corporate greed and the encroachment upon communities that do not have a voice is well illustrated in this story about the great lengths that a tribe must go through in order to save lives and preserve their land, culture and community。 This is an emotional read as it is hard to not also see the parallel stories that are going on all around us。

Teddy Copeland

This was a hard read。 So sad。 One review I read called it "quietly devastating。" And yet, I learned so much about the African culture。 The author did a wonderful job of painting for us all the shades of a hauntingly beautiful and difficult dilemma。 This was a hard read。 So sad。 One review I read called it "quietly devastating。" And yet, I learned so much about the African culture。 The author did a wonderful job of painting for us all the shades of a hauntingly beautiful and difficult dilemma。 。。。more

Faith

Too slow and fable-like for me。

Tika

nice book